August 22, 2003

Taking the heat  

The IHT has an interesting article on the French reaction to the heat wave by Eric Klinenberg, the author of Heat Wave: A Social Autopsy of Disaster in Chicago. Klinenberg draws some parallels between the two catastrophes in terms of public policy breakdowns, but uses the political fallout to illustrate an important difference between French and American politics - or at least, Chicago politics:

Yet the French and American responses to the heat crises have not been identical. Dr. Abenhaïm resigned because French political culture demands governmental accountability for failed policy programs, and because French journalists aggressively documented the ways that the state neglected to protect the vulnerable. In the United States, however, no federal officials faced criticism after the deadly American heat wave of 1995. Chicago leaders made it through the crisis unscathed, too. One group of activists and advocates for the elderly demanded that the mayor's office accept responsibility for the crisis. Yet a leading newspaper columnist trivialized their claims, writing that "trying to blame the mayor for an act of God is not only unfair, it also does an injustice by wrongfully framing the debate."
Thanks to Chris Bertram at Crooked Timber for the link.

Comments
bigoldgeek  {August 22, 2003}

Klinenberg's book is great - an ddepressing if you live in Chicago. His conclusions could apply to almost any large American city.


He's tough on the "paramilitary" organizations like the Police and Fire Departments who were assigned repsonsibilities for care they shoudn't have. He saves his most damning analysis for Da Mare - accusing him of government by press release - and the local press who just plain missed the story and swallowed the spin the Mayor gave to the story.


Post a comment










Remember personal
information?